A Contemplation on the Role of Gender in One's Identity: A Critical Review of Witt's "Uni-Essentialism" Thesis

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 PhD Graduate, Department of Philosophy, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran

2 M.A. of Philosophy of Science, Amirkabir University, Tehran, Iran.

3 PhD of Philosophy, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Metaphysics of Gender is a branch of Feminist Philosophy in which the metaphysical issues about "Gender" are discussed. Charlotte Witt is a feminist philosopher, who analyzes gender from a particular point of view. Witt names her theory "Uni-Essentialism" which is an essentialist theory of gender, while differing deeply from customary essentialist theories. She avoids the current framework of debate between Realists and Nominalists, because her main question is about the role of gender in one's identity. She says that there are always some conflicts between norms of various social roles one occupies, and for this reason we all need a unifying normative principle. According to Witt, gender is that normative principle, which unifies and organizes all other roles. So, gender is essential for everyone, in an Aristotalian sense. In this paper the Uni-Essentialism thesis of Witt is analyzed and its weaknesses are discussed. Finally we will suggest some points for improvement and modification of the theory.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

-       Asghari, Muhammad; Karimi, Bayan (2020) Deconstruction and Deontologicalization of the subject and gender identity: De Beavoir and Butler, in Journal of Metaphysik, Vol.12, No.1, Ser No (29), Pages: 131-146 at https://journals.ui.ac.ir/article_25294_982be42e43bb3ddd5c1ca181bef232fa.pdf
-       De Beauvoir, S. (1989) the Second Sex, Translator and Editor: H.M.Parshley, London: Jonathan Cape.
-       Butler, J. (1990) “Performative Acts and Gender Constitution”, in Performing Feminisms, S-E. Case (ed.), Baltimore: John Hopkins University.
-       Butler, J. (1999) Gender Trouble, London: Routledge, 2nd edition
-       Chodorow Nancy (1995), “Family Structure and Feminine Personality”, in Feminism and Philosophy, N. Tuana, and R. Tong (eds.), Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

-       Kohlberg, Lawrance (1981) The Philosophy of Moral Development Moral Stages and the Idea of Justice: Essays on Moral Developmen, USA: Harper & Row.

-       Moi, T. (1999) What is a Woman?, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
-       Oudshoorn, Nelly (2010) Beyond the Natural Body: An Archaeology of Sex Hormones, Trans. Parvane Ghasemian, Tehran: Shirazeh Pub. (in Persian)
-       Schiebinger, L. (1999) Has Feminism Changed Science, Harvard University Press.
-       Spelman, E. (1988) Inessential Woman, Boston: Beacon Press.
-       Stoljar, Natalie (2011) “Different Women: Gender Realism-Nominalism Debate”, in Feminist Metaphysics: Exploration in the Ontology on Sex Gender and the Self, Edit. C. Witt, Springer.
-       Stone, Alison (2004) Essentialism and Anti-Essentialism in Feminist Philosophy, Institute for Environment, Philosophy and Public Policy, Lancaster University.
-       Witt Clarlotte. (2011) The Metaphysics of Gender, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
-       Young, I. M. (1997) “Gender as Seriality: Thinking about Women as a Social Collective”, in Intersecting Voices, I. M. Young, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
-       Young, I. M. (2005) Throwing Like a Girl and Other Essays: On Female Body and Experience, USA: Oxford University Press.
Send comment about this article
CAPTCHA Image

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics