Document Type : Research Paper
Author
Professor of Philosophy and Head of the Research Ethics Committee, The Islamic College, an academic partner with Middlesex University, UK; Adjunct Professor of Philosophy of Science, National Research Institute for Science Policy, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Since the emergence of modernity, and in response to its myriad aspects and potentials, which are constantly unfolding, countless reactions have kept emerging in almost all quarters of the globe. A large variety of anti-modern reactions, the common core of which is perhaps the idea that modernity, in one way or another, is illegitimate, stand out among these responses. According to some of these anti-modern responses, modernity has usurped the characteristics and features of religion, which has been the soul as well as the main shaping force of the pre-modern era and has reproduced it in a corrupted form. Two German-speaking philosophers, Karl Popper and Hans Blumenberg, are among the intellectuals who have defended modernity against the onslaught of anti-modern tendencies. In this paper, I briefly, though critically, compare and contrast the approaches as well as some of the arguments of these two thinkers in defence of modernity.
Keywords
Ali, J. A. (2023). Modernity, Its Crisis and Islamic Revivalism, Religions 14, 15.
https://doi.org/10.3390/rel14010015.
https://doi.org/10.3390/rel14010015.
Andrews, J. & Shen, K. (1988). A Century in Crisis: Modernity and Tradition in the Art of Twentieth-Century China, The Guggenheim Museum.
Arblaster, A. (1971). Vision and Revision: A Note on the Text of Isaiah Berlin's Four Essays on Liberty, Political Studies 19, 81-86.
Azarfaam, M. (2023). Modernity Is Legitimate, Qoqnus Publications. (in Persian)
Bartley, W. (1990). Unfathomed Knowledge, Unmeasured Wealth, Open Court.
Bhattacharya, S. (2017). The crisis of modernity: realism and the postcolonial Indian novel. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Warwick.
Berger, P. (2014). The Many Altars of Modernity, Walter de Gruyter, Inc.
Blumenberg, H. (1983/1985). The Legitimacy of the Modem Age, Translated by R. M. Wallace, The MIT Press.
Blumenberg, H. (1987). The Genesis of the Copernican World, The MIT Press.
Blumenberg, H. (1988). Work on Myth, The MIT Press.
Blumenberg, H. (2010). Theorie der Lebenswelt, edited by: Manfred Sommer, Suhrkamp.
Blumenberg, H. (2020). History, Metaphors, Fables: A Hans Blumenerg Reader, Edited, translated, with an introduction by H. Bajohr, F. Fuchs, & J. P. Kroll, Cornell University Press.
Boggs, C. (1993). Intellectuals and the crisis of modernity, State University of New York Press.
Bragagnolo, C. M. (2011). Legitimacy and Legality: Carl Schmitt and the Dialectic of Modernity, Unpublished PhD Dissertation, Stony Brook University.
Chorell, T. G. (2021). Unsecularising history and politics: Jayne Svenungsson and Karl Löwith on meaning in history, International Journal of Philosophy and Theology, 82(2), 176-192.
Davies, J. (2021). Between Realism and Revolt: Governing Cities in the Crisis of Neoliberal Globalism, Bristol University Press.
Del Noce, A. (2014). The Crisis of Modernity, Montreal, McGill-Queen's University Press.
Desserud, D. (1995). Critique of Modernity, by Alain Touraine, Canadian Journal of Political Science, 28(4), 785-786.
Dijksterhuis, E. J. (1961). The Mechanization Of The World Picture: Pythagoras To Newton, Oxford University Press.
Dostoevski, F. (1879). Brothers Karamazov, English translation by Constance Garnett [2015], First Avenue Editions, A division of Learner Publishing Group, Inc.
Dura, P. (2014). The Crisis of Global Modernity Asian Traditions and a Sustainable Future, Cambridge University Press.
Ebrahimi, Z. (2023). Fundamental Delay in the Enlightenment, Rooz-e Gar-e Nou publications. (in Persian)
Elvin, M. (1986). A Working Definition of “Modernity” Past and Present, No. 113, 209-213.
Encylopedia Britannica. (2023). Modernity, https://www.britannica.com/topic/modernity.
Faber, R. (1984). Eric Voegelin: Gnosis-Verdacht als polit(olog)isches Strategem, in Taubes (ed.), Gnosis und Politik, 230-248.
Gibbs, N. (2019). Modern Constitutional Legitimacy and Political Theology: Schmitt, Peterson and Blumenberg, Law and Critique, 30: 67–89.
Gillespie, M. A. (2008). The Theological Origins of Modernity, University of Chicago Press.
Gorham, G., et al. (eds.) (2016). The Language of Nature: Reassessing the Mathematization of Natural Philosophy in the Seventeenth Century, Minnesota University Press.
Griffioen, S. (2019). Secularisation between Faith and Reason: Reinvestigating the Lowith-Blumenberg Debate, New German Critique: an Interdisciplinary Journal of German Studies, 46(1 (136)), 71-101. https://doi.org/10.1215/0094033X-7214681.
Gordon, P. (2019). Secularization, Genealogy, and the Legitimacy of the Modern Age: Remarks on the Lowith-Blumenberg Debate, Journal of the History of Ideas, 80(1), 147-170.
Gramsci, A. (1994). Letters from Prison, 19th December 1929, in Letters from Prison (Vol. 1), Columbia University Press.
Hell, J. (2009). Katechon: Carl Schmitt’s Imperial Theology and the Ruins of the
Guénon, R. (1927/2017). The Crisis of the Modern World, Sophia Perennis.
Heidenreich, F. (2020). Politische Metaphorologie: Hans Blumenberg heute, Online Publisher: J. B. Metzler.
Hell, J. (2009). Katechon: Carl Schmitt’s Imperial Theology and the Ruins of the
Future, The Germanic Review, 283-326.
Herskowitz, D. (2021). Karl Löwith’s Secularization Thesis and the Jewish Reception of Heidegger, Religions 12: 411. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel12060411.
Hinde, J. (2000). Jacob Burckhardt and the Crisis of Modernity, McGill-Queen's University Press.
Hogg, H. (ed.) (1968). Man and His World/Terres des hommes: The Noranda Lectures, Expo 67/Les Conferences Noranda/L'Expo 67, University of Toronto Press.
Horkheimer, M. & Adorno, T. (1973). Dialectic of enlightenment: philosophical fragments; edited by G. S. Noerr, translated by E. Jephcott, Allen Lane. (The book was originally published in German in 1947).
Hunt, L. (2008). Measuring Time, Making History, Central European University Press.
Husserl, E. (1970). The crisis of European sciences and transcendental phenomenology; an introduction to phenomenological philosophy, translated by D. Carr, Northwestern University.
Kadlec, E. (2008). «opper’s ‘Negative Utilitarianism’: From Utopia to Reality. In P. Markl & E. Kadlec, (eds), Karl Popper's Response to 1938. Peter Lang. pp. 107-21.
Kolakowsky, L. (1986). Modernity on Endless Trial, Encounter, lxvi, reprinted in Modernity on Endless Trial, University of Chicago Press.
Kosik, K. (1995). The Crisis of Modernity: essays and observations from the 1968 era, Romnan & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Kroll, J. P. (2010). A Human End to History? Hans Blumnberg, Karl Lowith and Carl Schmitt on Secularization and Modernity, Unpublished PhD Dissertation, Princeton University.
Löwith, K. (1949). Meaning in History, University of Chicago Press.
Löwith, K. (1964). Das Verhängnis des Fortschritts, in Kuhn/Wiedmann (eds.), Die Philosophie und die Frage nach dem Fortschritt, Pustet.
Löwith, K. (1968). Progress: A Fatality, in Man and his world. Terre des hommes. The Noranda lectures. Les conférences Noranda. Expo 67, edited by Helen Hogg, University of Toronto Press.
Magee, B. (1973). Popper, Fontana.
Maxwell, N. (2006). The Enlightenment Programme and Karl Popper, in Karl Popper: A Centenary Assessment: Life and Times, and Values in a World of Facts, Edited by I. Jarvie, D. Miller, K. Milford, Routledge.
Maxwell, N. (2017). Karl Popper, Science and Enlightenment, UCL Press.
McAllister, T. (1995). The Crisis of Modernity, chapter 3 of Revolt Against Modernity: Leo Strauss, Eric Voegelin, and the Search for a Post Liberal Order, University Press of Kansas.
Meyer, M. (1989). Modernity as a Crisis for the Jews, Modern Judaism, 9(2), 151-164.
Miller, D. (2006/2017). Out of Error: Further Essays on Critical Rationalism, Routledge.
Nicholls, A. (2016). Hans Blumenberg on Political Myth: Recent Publications from the ‘Nachlass’, The Jerusalem Philosophical Quarterly, 65, pp. 3-33.
Nietzsche, F. (1883). Thus Spoke Zarathustra: A Book for All and None, English translation by R. J. Hollingdale in 1892/1974, Penguin.
Notturno, M. (2000). Science and the Open Society: In Defense of Reason and the Freedom of Thought, Central European University Press.
O'Brien, C. (2000). Jacob Burckhardt and the Crisis of Modernity, History: Reviews of New Books, 29(1), 30-30.
Oram, M. (2022). The Ethos of the Enlightenment and the Discontents of Modernity, Routledge.
Pippin, R. (1997). Idealism as Modernism: Hegelian Variations, Cambridge University Press.
Popper, K. (1944). The poverty of historicism, I. Economica 11 (42): 86–103.
Popper, K. (1945a). The poverty of historicism, II. Economica 11 (43): 119–137.
Popper, K. (1945b). The poverty of historicism, III. Economica 12 (46): 69–89.
Popper, K. (1945/1966). The Open Society and Its Enemies, London.
Popper, K. (1957). The Poverty of Historicism, 2nd ed. 1972, Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Popper, K. (1959/2002). The Logic of Scientific Discovery, Routledge. Originally published as Logik der Forschung in 1935, Verlag von Julius Springer.
Popper, K. (2008). After The Open Society: Selected Social and Political Writings, edited by: J. Shearmur & P. N. Turner, Routledge.
Popper, K. (1963/2002). Conjectures and Refutations, Routledge.
Popper, K. (1982/1988). The Open Universe: An Argument for Indeterminism, Routledge.
Popper, K. (1983). Realism and the Aim of Science, Routledge.
Popper, K. (1994). The Myth of the Framework: In Defence of Science and Rationality, Routledge.
Popper, K. (1994/2000). In Search of a Better World, Routledge.
Popper, K. (1999). All Life Is Problem-Solving, Routledge.
Popper, K, & Eccles, J. (1981/1985). The Self and Its Brain, Springer-Verlag.
Quijano, A. (1989). Paradoxes of Modernity in Latin America, International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society, 3(2), 147-177.
Rasmussen, U. H. (2009). The Memory of God Hans Blumenberg's Philosophy of Religion, unpublished PhD Thesis, Theological Faculty, University of Copenhagen.
Rossouw, J. (2014). Spirit Matters: Life After Secularism and Religion?, in Matthew Sharpe and Dylan Nickelson, Editors Secularisations and Their Debates Perspectives on the Return of Religion in the Contemporary West, Springer Dordrecht, 75-92.
Ryan, A. (2012). The making of modern liberalism, Princeton University Press.
Shearmur, J. (1996). The political thought of Karl Popper, Routledge.
Schmidt, J. (2013). Isaiah Berlin & Karl Popper on Liberty & Enlightenment (Part I, II, III), https://persistentenlightenment.com/2013/04/14/popperberlinpart/ (accessed 12/05/2023)
Schmitt, C. (1947/1991). Glossarium: Aufzeichnungen der Jahre, 1947–1951. Ed. Eberhard Freiherr von Medem. Duncker and Humblot.
Schmitt, C. (1985/2005). Political Theology: four chapters on the concept of sovereignty, University of Chicago Press.
Schmitt, C. (2006). The Nomos of the Earth in the International Law of Jus Publicum Europaeum, Trans. G. L. Ulmen. Telos Publishing.
Schmitt, C. (1970/2008). Political Theology II The Myth of the Closure of any Political Theology, Polity Press.
Schmitt, C. (1950/2009). Three Possibilities for a Christian Conception of History, Telos, 167-170; originally published as “Drei Stufen historischer Sinngebung” (1950) [book review], reprinted in Hans Blumenberg/Carl Schmitt: Briefwechsel 1971–1978 (2007)
Schmitt, C. (1991). Glossarium. Aufzeichnungen der Jahre 1947-1951, Duncker & Humblot.
Svenungsson, J. (2014). A Secular Utopia Remarks on the Löwith–Blumenberg Debate, in Elena Namli, Jayne Svenungsson and Alana Vincent (eds), Jewish Thought, Utopia and Revolution. Rodopi, 69–84.
Shayegan, D. (1977a). L’Asie Face A L’Occident: Essai sur les mutations socio-cultelles des sociétés traditionelles, Amir Kabir Publications. (in persian)
Shayegan, D. (1997b). Idos of the Mind and Perennial Memory: Essays in Comparative Philosophy, Amir Kabir Publications. (in Persian)
Shearmur, J. (1996). The political thought of Karl Popper, Routledge.
Strauss, L. (1975). The Three Waves of Modernity, in Political Philosophy: Six Essays, ed. Hilail Gildin, Pegasus-Bobbs-Merrill.
Strauss, L. (1997). Jewish Philosophy and the Crisis of Modernity: Essays and Lectures in Modern Jewish Thought – Edited by H. G. Kenneth, State University of New York Press.
Svenungsson, J. (2014). A Secular Utopia Remarks on the Löwith–Blumenberg Debate, in Elena Namli, Jayne Svenungsson and Alana Vincent (eds), Jewish Thought, Utopia and Revolution. Rodopi, 69–84.
Taubes, J. (1984). (ed.), Gnosis und Politik, Fink, and Paderborn: Schöningh.
Urban, M. (2018). Martin Buber: His Intellectual and Scholarly Legacy, Brill.
Voegelin, E. (1952). The New Science of Politics, University of Chicago Press.
von Weizsäcker, C. F. (1964). The Relevance of Science (New York and Evanston; Harper and Row. This book was based on von Weizsäcker’ Gifford Lecturer at the University of Glasgow in a lecture series delivered during the academic year 1959–1960.
Wallace, R. (1981). Progress, Secularization and Modernity: The Löwith-Blumenberg Debate, New German Critique, No. 22, Special Issue on Modernism, pp. 63-79.
Watkins, J. (1974). The Unity of Popper's Thought, in P. A. Schilpp (ed.), The Philosophy of Karl Popper, Open Court, pp. 371-412.
Williams, D. (1989). Truth, Hope and Power: The Thought of Karl Popper, University of Toronto Press.
)
Send comment about this article