Journal of Philosophical Investigations

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Associate Professor of Philosophy Department, University of Tabriz, Iran

Abstract

Avicenna in two parts of the book of Al-Shifa (کتاب الشفاء) or The Book of Healing reports the theory of Platonic Ideas or Forms: first account is in the chapter 10 from the second book in the Demonstration Treatise (رسالة البرهان) and second account is in the chapter 2 from the seventh book in the Theology Treatise (رسالة الالهیّات). Both reports have explanations of the theory of Platonic Ideas and then some critiques of the theory. Here we will discuss only Avicenna's description and explanations of the theory of Ideas; what is Avicenna's understanding from Plato's Ideas? At the present essay it is necessary to investigate the range of familiarity that Avicenna has with Platonic Ideas, Aristotle's role in this familiarity and the philosophical functions of the Ideas in Avicenna's understanding and identification of them. First of all, Avicenna thinks that Platonic Ideas are universals and, on this description, he erects other descriptions of their truth. It is vital to know that Avicenna's familiarity with Platonic Forms is essentially mediate; that's by way of Aristotle's works including both descriptions and criticisms of those forms. Review and analysis of Avicenna's texts brings us to the three arguments of Platonists for the existence of Ideas: the argument from the sciences, the one over many arguments and the object of thought argument.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Aristotle. (1993). On Ideas (Aristotle's Criticism of Plato's Theories of Ideas), Gail Fine, Clarendon Press Oxford.
Aristotle. (1984). The Complete Works of Aristotle, vol. 2, the revised Oxford translation & edited by J. Barnes, Princeton University Press.
Aristotel. (1988). Metaphysics (Mab'd al-Tabi'a), trans. Sh. Khorasani, 2nd Edition, publishing Goftar. (In Persian)
Aristotel. (2004). Isagoge & Categories, translated by M. Khansari, 1st Edition Academic Publishing Center. (In Persian)
Avicenna. (2005). The Metaphysics of the Healing, a parallel English- Arabic text translated, introduced and annotated by M. E. Marmura, Brigham Young University Press.
Bluck, R. C. (1955). Plato's Phaedo, International Library of Philosophy. (new print by Routledge, 2010)
Ghaffari, A. (2018). The Critical analysis of the interpretation of Avicenna and Mirdamad of the theory of the Platonic Forms based on the perspectives of Seyyed Ahmad Alavi and Molla Mohammad Aqajani, Journal of philosophy of religion, 15(1), 275-291 (In Persian) https://doi.org/10.22059/jpht.2018.230778.1005462
Graham, W. D. (2020). Fragments of Pre-Socratic writings, trans. B. Dehkordi, 2nd Edition, Amir Kabir Publications. (In Persian)
Graham, W. D. (2010). Texts of Early Greek Philosophy, The Complete Fragments and Selected Testimonies of the Major Pre-Socratic, Parts 1 and 2, Cambridge University Press.
Ibn Sina, Η. (2007). The treatise of Demonstration, from the book of Healing, research by A. Afifi, (Offset in Iran) Zawi al-Qurabi Publications (In Arabic)
Ibn Sina, H. (2005). Description of the Healing, vol. 1 & 2., Research and writing M. Garaviyan, Publications of Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute. (In Persian)
Ibn Sina, H. (2009). Theology (Metaphysics) from the book of healing, Editing and translation by I. Dadju, Amir Kabir Publications. (In Persian)
Ibn Sina, H. (1994). Demonstration of the Healing, trans. M. Gawam Safari, Fekr-e Rooz Publications. (In Persian)
Misbah Yazdi, M. T. (2016). Commentary of the Theology of the Healing, vol. 3, 1st Editon, Publications of Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute. (In Persian)
Mutahhari, M. (1997). Lessons on the Theology of the Healing, vol.3, 1st Editon, Hekmat Publications. (In Persian)
Plato. (1998). Plato Complete Works, edited with introduction & notes by J. M. Cooper, associate editor: D. S. Hutchinson, Hackett Publishing Company.
Plato. (1988). Plato Complete Works, trans. M. H. Lotfi Tabrizi, Khwarezmi Publications. (In Persian)
Plotinus. (1992). Theology (Theologia); Plotinus among the Arabs, texts by A. Badavi, Bidar Publications. (In Arabic)
Saket, A. H. (2021). Universal and particular in Plato's works, Journal of Philosophical Investigations, 15(37), 952-973. https://doi.org/10.22034/jpiut.2021.48161.2995 (In Persian)
Sadr Majles, M. (2008). Plato and separation of the Idea of Beauty from the universal concept of the Beauty in the Symposium, Journal of Philosophical Investigations, 2(203), 61-83. (In Persian)
Tawaziyani, Z. (2007). Ιbn-Sina in challenge with Plato's theory of Ideas, Avicennian Philosophy Journal, 38 (11), 24-45. (In Persian)
Tywai, M. A (2009). Perpatetics and the theory of Ideas, Ayeneh Ma‘refat, 8(2), 35-59 (In Persian)
Tywai, Μ. A. (2011). Plato's Ideas from the point of view of Aristotle and Ibn-Sina, Journal of Islamic Studies 87(2), 9-32. (In Persian)
CAPTCHA Image