Document Type : Research Paper
Author
PhD in Philosophy, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
In this essay, we try to address a fundamental issue in the philosophy of science, namely the conflict between realism and antirealism in Quine's philosophy. There seems to be an inner tension in his views on the question of the reality of unobservable entities or reference of theoretical terms. In order to refute his seemingly inconsistent position, we first begin with the concept of ontological commitment, which he formulated in contrast to the position of his teacher, Carnap. In the following, by expressing the thesis of "the inscrutability of reference" and "naturalized epistemology", we show that there seems to be a conflict between Quine's views. In the end, even with the acceptance of non-conflict, Quine's defense of realism is still not immune to criticism.
Keywords
Main Subjects
- Allaire, E. B. (1963) "Bare Particulars", Philosophical studies, 14: 1-8.
- Aristotle (1992) "Metaphysics", A New Aristotle Reader, trans. J. L. Ackrill, Oxford University Press, third edition.
- Armstrong, D. M. (1978) Nominalism and Realism, Cambridge University Press.
- Armstrong, D. M. (1997) A world of State of Affairs, Cambridge University Press.
- Bergmann, G. (1967) Realism: A Critique of Brentano and Meinong, University of Wisconsin Press.
- Bunnin, N.; Jiyuan, Yu. (2004) The Blackwell Dictionary of Western Philosophy, Blackwell Publishing, First Published.
- Campbell, K. (1981) "The Metaphysic of Abstract Particulars", Midwest Studies in Philosophy, 6: 477-488.
- Campbell, K. (1983) "Abstract Particulars and the Philosophy of Mind", Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 61.
- Campbell, K. (1990) Abstract Particulars, Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
- Hoffman and Rosenkrantz (1997) Substance, its Nature and Existence, Routdledge, first published.
- Lock, J. (1690) An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, P. Nidditch (ed.) Oxford: Clarendon Press (1975).
- Loux, M. (1978) Substance and Attribute: A Study in ontology, Dordrecht: D. Reidel Publishing Company.
- Loux, M. (1998) Metaphysics a Contemporary Introduction, Rutledge, first Published.
- Mahoozi, Reza (2012) The Concept of Substance in Analytic Philosophy in Resent Century, Sadra Publishing. (in Persian)
- Moreland, J. P. (1989) "Keith Campbell and the Trope View of Predication", Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 67.
- Parsons, G. G. (2001) Bundle Theory, Substratum and Spacetime, Macmillan University Press.
- Robinson, H. (2004) Substance", in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/substance/
- Russell, B. (1948) An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth, London University Press.
- Searle, J. R. (1963) "Particulars", in Science, Perception and Reality. New York: The Humanities Press.
- Van Cleve, J. (1985) "Three Versions of The Bundle Theory", Philosophical Studies, 47, edit. Steven D. Hales, Bloomsburg University, Wadsworth Publishing Company.
- Van Inwagen, Peter (2007) Metaphysics, in Stanford encyclopedia of philosoohy, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/metaphysics.
- Zimmerman, D. (1997) "Distinct Indiscernibles and the Bundle Theory", Mind, 106.
)
Send comment about this article